Github Vs Bitbucket Vs Visual Studio Team Services

githubAs a developer using source control and git is bread and butter of what we do. Github is probably the most popular and widely known hosting service for source control but I have also used Bitbucket and Visual Studio Team Services. Lets have a look at each one and what they offer. Note while I have included prices I have only tried out the free versions.

Github

URL: https://github.com/
Private Repositories: Not Available for free
Public Repositories: Unlimited
Team Size: Unlimited
Prices: $7 per month for unlimited private repositories, $25 per month for 5 users then $9 per month per user

This is probably the most widely used service for hosting code. Over 13 million repositories of code. This is an ideal solution if you want your code to be publicly viewable, but take care not to publish passwords, private keys or your companies trade secrets. Every developer should have a Github account for displaying bits of code they are proud of.

There are a number of externally built APIs that link into Github for doing extra features, like building, code coverage etc

BitbucketBitbucket

URL: https://bitbucket.org/
Private Repositories: Unlimited
Public Repositories: Unlimited
Team Size: Less than 5
Prices: $10 per month for 10 Users, $100 per month for 100 Users, $200 per month for Unlimited Users

At my last job we used Bitbucket extensively for all our projects. All the code was private so only the team could access it, however before I left we were approaching the 5 user limit (but looking at these prices cost seems very reasonable)

Visual Studio Team ServicesVisual Studio Team Services

URL: https://www.visualstudio.com/team-services/
Private Repositories: Unlimited
Public Repositories: Not Available
Team Size: Less than 5
Prices: $30 per month for 10 users, and other features paid for via Azure Invoices

Visual Studio Team Services or VSTS is Microsoft’s version control solution and I have only just started using it, however what I have seen I like. There are lots of options for building your code so VSTS is more than just hosting your code it is verging on a Continuous Integration/Delivery solution. Being a Microsoft product there are numerous links to Azure and it is easy to deploy stuff to that platform.

All three have options for tracking issues but VSTS have options to add Stakeholder users which would allow none developers to add and keep track of issues and progress with them.

If I want to run tests, look at code coverage VSTS is probably the solution I would go for, if I want something that is public I would go for Github. What do you think which of these is your favourite?

This post has already been read 883 times!

Simon Foster on GithubSimon Foster on LinkedinSimon Foster on Twitter
Simon Foster
Web Developer
I have worked in SysAdmin and IT Management but now work as a Web Developer. I love everything IT related and I am trying to learn as much as I can especially about DevOps. Why not follow me on twitter?